Complaints Lodged with RTE concerning the promotion of Google to School Children
national |
education |
news report 
Wednesday December 03, 2008 17:37
by Mark C - CCFE (Campaign for Commercial-Free Education)
oscailt at indymedia dot ie
Campaign for Commercial-Free Education campaigns against the imposition of advertisements in to school curricula (again).
The recently launched "Doodle 4 Google" campaign is a slick method of promoting Google to school children, without their consent, and usually without the consent of their parents. It is a scheme that is heavy on Google brand recognition, but very low on curricular relevance; this is something that CCFE has come to expect from commercial schemes that are promoted in schools.
Today, CCFE launched a campaign against RTE for its one-sided version of the "Doodle for Google" piece which aired on Nov. 19th on The Den. Speaking about the programme, Joe Fogarty, a primary school principal, had the following to say: "“Doodle 4 Google” promotion seeks to make Google's corporate logo the focus of art lessons for school children as young as 5 years of age."
Continuing, he claimed: "The RTE report gave glowing, uncritical coverage to the marketing scheme and featured children from Tiermohan NS in Kildare as well as a company spokesperson.
"Blandly promoting a commercially-driven exercise is not “providing News and Current Affairs that is fair and impartial, accurate and challenging” (RTE’s Strategic Framework Values p1). The widespread opposition to in-school marketing was entirely absent in this report. RTE should not be airing “Advertorials” straight from the marketing department to the childrens’ TV.”
Furthermore, the INTO (the union representing primary schools) has made recommendations against commercialism in schools, saying: “Commercial logos, slogans, brand names or product orientated activities should not be presented to children in class either through posters, worksheets or certificates.”
Further information about this campaign, and also other anti-commercialism in schools ventures, can be found at the link below.
Comments (4 of 4)
Jump To Comment: 1 2 3 4Below is the text of a letter/email campaign that has been initiated by CCFE. Please copy/paste it and send it to:
complaints@rte.ie
theden@rte.ie
Regards,
Mark Conroy.
_____________________ begins _____________________
Dear ____________
I would like to register a complaint regarding a report on children's news show News2Day (19 Nov 2008) about the "Doodle 4 Google" promotion in schools.
This commercaial promotion (sent unsolicited to schools) asks teachers to make the sponsors' corporate logo the focus of art lessons for school children as young as 5 years of age. Your report, aimed at children of primary school age, gave glowing, uncritical coverage to the marketing scheme and featured children from Tiermohan NS in Kildare studying Google's logo as well as comment from a company spokesperson.
My objection is based on the following grounds:
a) RTE shouldn't be packaging commercial marketing initatives as childrens' programming.
b) If publicity is to be given to a commercial promotion in schools, it must acknowledge that there is a strong opposing perspective and present balanced coverage.
a)
The "Doodle 4 Google" competition is a marketing promotion. Google are NOT featured in the Visual Arts Curriculum for Primary Schools. The entry guidelines read "Please ensure that the Google logo is clearly visible and recognisable." "Write the word 'Google' on the board and show the pupils a print out of the logo template."
Bland promotion of such a commercially-driven exercise is not "providing News and Current Affairs that is fair and impartial, accurate and challenging" (RTE's Strategic Framework Values p1)
RTE which commits to "ensure that children are respected as young citizens with a valued contribution to make and a voice of their own" (Public Broadcasting Charter p3) should not be airing soft-focus "Advertorials" straight from the marketing department to the childrens' TV.
b)
Notwithstanding our own Campaign, there exists a solid consensus among educators that children should not be subject to commercial marketing in school. This established position was lamentably absent in this one sided, promotional report.
The INTO have stated, (June 07) : "Commercial logos, slogans, brand names or product orientated activities should not be presented to children in class either through posters, worksheets or certificates."
The Irish Primary Principals Network concur that (Feb 07): "The promotion of commercial products, aimed at a captive audience of children in schools, contravenes and undermines many of the core values of education."
Other RTE reports on commercial advertising (For example see http://www.rte.ie/news/2008/0107/6news_av.html?2323434,...l,230), have been fair and balanced in their presentation of the issues - the same could not be said of the report on 19th November which was broadcast directly to children.
In closing I would like to see "impartial, accurate and challenging" reporting of this important issue. Perhaps you would consider a feature on one of the 13 primary schools recently awarded Commercial-Free status by the INTO in recognition of the their policy to protect children from the kind of commercial-exploitation so lauded in the News2Day report.
Regards,
Your Name Here
_____________________ ends _____________________
I thought that google was based here? Schoolkids will want to know of its existence, and the cleverer ones will learn more from it than from school.
Only once have I tried an ad alongside google, and the link didn't work. So much for its whizzo commercialism....
This is nothing short of branding.
The success of branding is absolute and exploits one of the greatest of human failings and weaknesses. Kids so young exposed to capitalist marketing and such pre-conditioning is an outrage. They get enough of that crap in everyday life, but getting it in school now and promoted by RTE (Refuse to Tell the Electorate), leaves one reeling in astonishment
Google or yahoo. Nike or rebok. Coke or pepsi. War on terror or terror, your with us or against us. It is disgusting to see such blatant branding on school children so young. There is no room to allow critical analysis of anything small or large in the classroom these days- not that there ever was much to begin with. The school criculum is being hi-jacked from first level through to 3rd level through corporatising education to the point where schools are sending out robots to sit in front of computers all day till they die to serve their masters of a capitalist profit making machine where the human element is almost non existent. Or the new yuppy type of marketeering class, with its buzz words and participation in the 'team' is how you will ensure your enlightenment.
Was it Hitler said....'give me a child till he is five and i will own him for life.... This is it folks....The Fourth Reich................only exaggerating.
I think it was the Jesuits actually!
Indymedia Ireland is a media collective. We are independent volunteer citizen journalists producing and distributing the authentic voices of the people. Indymedia Ireland is an open news project where anyone can post their own news, comment, videos or photos about Ireland or related matters.